Diary

Alcohol-free drinks at 58th Street in London

A jazz band performing on a small, dimly lit club stage, with a singer, pianist, saxophonist and guitarist, and cabaret tables in the foreground. A stock photograph, not 58th Street.

Lisa and I went to Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club in Peckham, London, on Sunday 25 October 2026, for the 1pm show. We’d booked a cabaret table. We get down to London a few times a year for concerts and shows, and this was one of those trips.

A jazz band performing on a small, dimly lit club stage, with a singer, pianist, saxophonist and guitarist, and cabaret tables in the foreground. A stock photograph, not 58th Street.
A jazz band in a dimly lit club — a stock photo, not 58th Street. Photo by Dimenshtein Olga / cottonbro studio, via Pexels.

The tickets were £155 each, plus a £4.85 fee each, booked on 2 October. That’s a proper night out, even if this one started in the early afternoon. When the tickets cost that much, I want to sit down with a drink I actually like, not spend the afternoon making do.

Before we booked, I messaged them on Facebook in August to ask for their alcohol-free drinks menu, because I could only find two drinks on the website. They wrote back: “We don’t have a full drinks menu to share ahead of the event, but I can assure you there is a great selection of non alcoholic cocktails available, as well as non alcoholic sparkling and beer, or soft drinks.” That mattered. We’ve learned to ask first, because the show is only half the outing if there’s nothing in the glass. On the strength of that reply, we went ahead.

We also pre-ordered a bottle of Wild Idol Alcohol-Free Sparkling White, at £50. That was for Lisa. It’s a good bottle, and she enjoyed it. I’m glad we ordered it in advance, because once we were there the choice for those of us not drinking was a lot narrower than “a great selection” had suggested.

For me, the only alcohol-free beer was Brooklyn Special Effects, and there were a few mocktails. That was it.

What we’d hoped for was fairly ordinary by the standards of a lot of venues now. A zero-alcohol gin and tonic. A bit more choice of alcohol-free beer. Some alcohol-free red and white wine, not only a sparkling bottle we had pre-ordered. A cider, perhaps. None of that was there.

In the end I asked for a Coke. They only had Diet Coke, which I don’t drink. So Lisa had the Wild Idol, and I didn’t really have a drink I wanted. It is a small thing on paper, a soft drink, but it rather finished the point off. When the alcohol-free list is already short, a regular cola is the simple fallback, and even that wasn’t available.

I want to be fair. They did have something. The Wild Idol was there if you pre-ordered it, Lisa liked it, and there was one alcohol-free beer and a few mocktails if you wanted them. I’m not saying we were offered nothing, and I won’t guess at why the list was so short on the day. I can only say what we found.

A great selection, though, it wasn’t. After a message like that, and at this price, I expected to be able to choose a drink and settle in, the same way anyone else at the table could. Instead I was looking at one beer, a few mocktails, and a Diet Coke I wasn’t going to drink. Lisa was fine, which I was glad about. It still left the two of us on uneven terms, her with a bottle she liked and me without a drink I would have chosen.

What would have made the difference

If 58th Street wanted to close that gap, it wouldn’t take a long list, and it wouldn’t take anything unusual. These are products a great many places now keep behind the bar as a matter of course.

A 0% gin, so a gin and tonic is actually possible. An alcohol-free red and an alcohol-free white, on top of the Wild Idol, so you are not limited to sparkling. A couple of alcohol-free beers rather than one, and a cider. And ordinary full-sugar soft drinks, not only Diet Coke. That would already feel like a proper choice. It would also be much closer to what most people mean when they hear that the selection is great.

Ask for the actual list before you book

If you’re thinking of booking, my advice is simple. Don’t stop at a general reassurance. Ask for the actual list, including beer, wine, spirits and soft drinks, and, if they can, get them to name the bottles. Ask whether you can pre-order something you already know you like, as we did with the Wild Idol. That pre-order made a real difference for Lisa. It didn’t solve the rest of the table, and it wouldn’t have helped me with a gin and tonic, a beer I wanted, or a Coke.

It’s worth asking about the soft drinks as well. It hadn’t occurred to me that a regular Coke might not be available.

We go out for the show, and we also go out to sit together with a drink we actually want. On that second point, 58th Street didn’t match what we had been told. The first thing I’d do, next time, is ask them to send the list first.

I’ve also written a short piece about going to gigs, concerts and shows without a drink, in our New Hobbies section.